Monday, September 12, 2016

Thoughts on the so called H-20 bomber

After the development of Y-20 and J-20, the next military major aviation project in China is the rumoured H-20 bomber project. Although we do not know the exact designation, PLAAF’s top officer, General Ma Xiatian, recently announced that China is developing a next generation, long-range bomber, which will be seen in near future. Just from his statement, I think it’s fair to say that the project is in advanced development. Since H-20 is a strategic platform, it would have even higher level of secrecy than J-20. Speculations over this next generation bomber project have already replaced J-20 and the fate of J-31 as the hottest subject on Chinese military boards. I remember back in 2009, a similar statement was said about J-20. The PLAAF officer said that the next generation fighter jet is expected to go into service in 8 to 10 years. We saw pictures of the first prototype less than 2 years later. And now, it appears that J-20 project will go into service in 2017, just 8 years after the original statement. From this, we can see that when a top level PLAAF officer makes a statement about a major strategic platform, it will usually be quite on the mark. From that, I would expect the first prototype to be built sometimes next year and make maiden flight in 2018. That also seems to be when our friend Huitong thinks the maiden flight will be.

From what I read on Huitong’s blog and other sources, it seems like 603 Institute/XAC will be the primary developer of this project. That would make a lot of sense given their work in the JH-7 series of fighter-bomber and H-6 series of bombers. With the completion of the primary development work for the Y-20 project, additional engineering resources are now available to really speed up H-20 development. Unfortunately, the “wall climbing” community isn’t as active in Xi’an as it is in Chengdu, so we might not see photos coming out as soon as in J-20. At the same time, H-20 should be considered a more classified project than J-20, so we would likely have fewer pictures and info on it than J-20. One only has to think about the classified nature of F-117 and B-2 compared to F-22/35 to imagine how secretive H-20 should be.

The next part is to look at what China has for attack and bomber project right now. China has operated H-6 bombers since first importing Tu-16 technology from Russia back in the 60s. Over time, XAC improved on the avionics and missiles carried by H-6 to develop various improved models fro PLAAF and PLANAF. When they got access to Spey engine, they also experimented installing it H-6 (but did not adopt it). More recently, XAC worked on the H-6K project, which made its maiden flight in 2007. H-6K was delayed due to engine issues, but resumed production in 2009 after they got D-30KP2 from Russia. Since they purchased large quantity of D-30, they have been able to produce about 1 regiment of H-6K (about 20 bombers) every 2 years. H-6K is a large improvement over earlier H-6 in range with payload. It can carry 6 KD-20s for long-range strike and have participated in numerous exercises. Most recently, it crossed Baishi channel in an exercise with Su-30s, early warning aircraft and refueling tankers. Even with all of this improvement, H-6K still pales in comparison to Tu-95MS and B-52 in range and payload. With the KD-20 missiles, H-6K can serve the role of missile carriers/bomb truck, but is not capable of longer ranged missions. Back in 2005, there were speculations that China was interested in Tu-22M3 backfire bombers, but that never happened. I think China was interested in bombers of that quality, but not used frames incapable of launching Chinese missiles. There were speculations a while back that China would develop a domestic version of backfire called H-18. However, that turned out to be a hoax. At this point, I think China would be interested in Tu-160 bomber, but Russia is probably not willing to sell such a strategic platform. For the past 5 years, we have seen induction of 3 H-6K regiments and many new types of missiles and bombers. H-6Ks have been installed with numerous types of electronics. I think the H-6K program serves as a good test bed for missiles and avionics that PLAAF would like to install on the next generation bomber. Once H-20 does join service, H-6K could still serve a role of bomb truck and EW aircraft.

So what would a H-20 bomber look like? The PLA’s definition of a long-range strategic bomber is a minimum range of 8,000 km (5,000 miles) without refueling and the capacity to carry a payload of more than 10 tons of air-to-ground ammunition. Considering that PLAAF it looking for such a bomber and has chosen to not develop its version of backfire, they are clearly looking for something more advanced than Tu-22M3. It would be a tremendous leap to go from H-6K to Tu-160 or B-1 bomber. Huitong’s blog indicated that China is looking for an even more advanced flying wing design akin to the B-2 bomber. If XAC is looking to develop something close to the capability of B-2, the leap from H-6K would be larger than any project in the history of Chinese military aviation (with only J-10 project as comparable). Fortunately, China already has tested out many elements needed for a modern bomber. First of all, it finally has a modern turbofan engine needed for such a bomber. B-1 bomber uses F-101, which was developed into F-110 used on F-15/16s. B-2 bomber uses F-118, which is a non-afterburning turbofan engine developed from F-110. So depending on whether XAC is looking for a supersonic bomber, they could either go with a variant of WS-10 with or without afterburner. In the future, they could also try a version of WS-15. In terms of sensors, they have already tested out various ground scanning radar, AESA radar, EW suites, FLIR/EO turret and laser designator on J-20 and H-6K. I certainly think they can develop some very capable for H-20. In terms of weaponry, stand off missiles, anti-radiation missiles and precision guided missiles have already been developed and in service with various attack aircraft. The big question is whether or not they have the stealth technology, advanced light materials, battlefield surveillance technology and FBW software needed to have a modern long-range LO signature bomber. The 601 Institute and Hongdu have been testing some of the technology since 2013 with the Sharp Sword UCAV, so it can share the data from testing with XAC. However, in order to scale that data up to something the size of a strategic bomber with 4 large turbofan engines, XAC has a lot of work ahead.

38 comments:

Neanderthal said...

Thanks for the post. It seems like a smaller version of the B-2 bomber. I assume the engine is the limiting factor at how large a plane they can build.

On a different note, did you read about the proposal to resurrect the An-225, the world's largest cargo plane in China? Eastern Arsenal has an article about this. with the transfer of technology, The engine will help add to the engine tech they have and another large engine option for other kinds of planes.

jobjed said...

If the H-20 is to have four WS-10-derived engines, or perhaps even WS-15-derived engines, I don't see why it would be a 'smaller' version of the B-2, considering that the B-2 itself is powered by four F110-derived engines. If anything, since the WS-10 and WS-15 have higher base performance than the early F110 variants on which the F118 is based, the H-20 could very well achieve greater thrust than the B-2, allowing it to be heavier.

Neanderthal said...

@jobjed, You are right. I compared the numbers given by Feng with what is listed by public sources but did not bother to check the size of the engine that the B-2 was using. Here are the numbers after accounting for the two different engines.

B-2 H-20

Range 6900 miles 5000 miles

payload 20-25 ton 10 ton

Engine F118 WS-10/WS-15

Max unit engine thrust 9.5 ton 15 ton/ 22 ton

Top speed Mach 0.95 ???


From these numbers, it looks like the H-20 will be a super-sonic bomber. The assumption is that WS-10 or WS-15 will be used for these birds.


jobjed said...

The maximum thrust ratings you gave for the WS-10 and WS-15 are only achievable while using afterburner. If the H-20 is to be a stealthy flying wing like the B-2, it's unlikely to have afterburning engines. The thrust achievable by non-afterburning WS-10s should only be slightly higher than the F118s'.

Neanderthal said...

If they are using similar thrust engine, how is it that they can't achieve the same range and payload? After all, the B-2 was built in the eighties and material science has advanced since that time to built a lighter aircraft.

jobjed said...

I'm fairly sure the H-20's range and payload will be similar if not slightly superior to the B-2. However, my point was that the thrust values you gave for the F118 and WS-10/WS-15 are misleading.

In your previous comment, you noted that the F118 had 9.5 tons of thrust and the WS-10 had 15 tons. That is misleading as the H-20 will almost definitely not use the WS-10. It will likely have an engine derived-from the WS-10 without afterburning capabilities. This means that whatever engine the H-20 uses will definitely not have 15 tons of thrust, a thrust level that could only be achieved when using afterburner. Instead, the H-20's engine will have a thrust level similar to the F118, maybe a little bit higher.

Neanderthal said...

@Jobjed,

Was not trying to disagree with you. I am sure you are more knowledgeable regarding the engines. Just trying to make sense of the numbers. I suppose 5000 miles is in the same range as 6900 miles, so we could argue that the range will end up being comparable. 20-25 tons payload for the B-2 is a lot more then the 10 tons for the H-20. It is difficult to reconcile this set of numbers.

I suppose it maybe that the efficiency of the WS-10 was not as good as the F118. This would explain both the shorten range and the smaller payload. If you look at the B-2, the empty weight is 79 tons, while the loaded weight is 168 tons. subtract the 20 tons of payload, the remainder 60 odd tons is fuel. Just a flying gas tank. If the efficiency of the engine is lower even by a little, that would eat into payload and range.

Neanderthal said...

You know I was reading about the specs of the B-21, it seems the spec was similar to the H-20 and inferior to the B-2 in terms of payload and range. Apparently, to evade modern air defenses, it is not enough to have a flying wing stealth design like the B-2, you also need to be able to fly low and blend in with the ground. Flying just off the ground cuts into both range and payload. You also need to have an engine with small diameter openings to minimize radar signature. The B-21 will have two 15 ton engines. There is an article at National Interest that talked about this at more detail.

The H-20 may end up even better than the B-2 in stealth (but will probably be inferior to the B-21).

Neanderthal said...

Also while the WS-10 will be used for the initial prototypes, they most likely will need to re-design the engine for the final production. The WS-10 is a low by-pass engine designed for supersonic flight. In exclusively subsonic flight profile, it is not as efficient. They will have to tweak the engine to optimize for subsonic flights.

Andrew Carter said...

Nice article and informative as well. for few of people like me this article is really helpful.
technological advances

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Feng said...

it seems like WS-10 without afterburners will be used for H-20 or an improved version of WS-10. Either way, they will build the bomber based on what the engine can support. So, I don't think it makes too much sense to argue over the thrust.

Bullion Jackpot Call said...

good informative blog,thanks for the post. It seems like a smaller version of the B-2 bomber.


Free Mcx Market Tips

Kavita Reddy said...

Gorgeous and stylish Mumbai Escorts Girls are available on 24*7 will give you Mumbai Escort Services with huge love and die heart feelings.
Mumbai Escorts
Escorts in Mumbai
Independent Mumbai Escorts
Independent Escorts in Mumbai

anti.insects7@gmail.com said...


الان نوفر لكم اكبر خدمة فى مكافحة حشرات للجناين من خلال تواصلك مع اسرع فريق خدمة عملاء لاكبر شركة متخصصة فى ابادة حشرات للمولات او تواصل من خلال زيارة موقعنا الالكترونى

Unknown said...

That's really interesting dobromed52.ru

Anonymous said...

teddy day messages for her
teddy day messages for him
promise's day wishes messages
promise day quote for husband

Unknown said...

Welcome to Escorts Services in Hyderabad along with Hyderabad Escorts offering Independent Escorts service in Hyderabad across city. Professional Independent Escorts services in Hyderabad make you most satisfied Lifetime experience at affordable rates.

More Details- http://www.payalkaur.com/

Chennai Pretty Girls said...

Chennai pretty Girls is your destination to find ultimate female escorts in Chennai. We profile high class independent girls for you erotic fun. Our classy and elegant models are ready to meet you in 5 Star hotels and anywhere in Chennai. Do call us for bookings.Chennai Escort Service

Vadodara Escort said...

Welcome to High Class Escorts Vadodara. Independent Escorts in Vadodara is a sensuous and exclusive
Independent Escorts in Vadodara

Priya Sharma said...

Meet Our High Profile Escorts in Pune / Pune Escorts

Wakad Escorts / Wakad Call Girls
Hinjewadi Escorts / Hinjewadi Call Girls
Nigdi Escorts / Nigdi Call Girls
Lonavala Escorts / Lonavala Call Girls
Baner Escorts / Baner Call Girls
Aundh Escorts / Aundh Call Girls

Get a Genuine Sex Services in Pune at an affordable price.

Email us at priya@booktopescorts.com

Priya Sharma said...

Meet Our High Profile Escorts in Pune / Pune Escorts

Wakad Escorts / Wakad Call Girls
Hinjewadi Escorts / Hinjewadi Call Girls
Nigdi Escorts / Nigdi Call Girls
Lonavala Escorts / Lonavala Call Girls
Baner Escorts / Baner Call Girls
Aundh Escorts / Aundh Call Girls

Get a Genuine Sex Services in Pune at an affordable price.

Email us at priya@booktopescorts.com

Credit Loan Solution said...

Are you tired of seeking loans and Mortgages,have you been turned down constantly By your banks and other financial institutions,We offer any form of loan to individuals and corporate bodies at low interest rate.If you are interested in taking a loan,feel free to contact us today,we promise to offer you the best services ever.Just give us a try,because a trial will convince you.What are your Financial needs?Do you need a business loan?Do you need a personal loan?Do you want to buy a car?Do you want to refinance?Do you need a mortgage loan?Do you need a huge capital to start off your business proposal or expansion? Have you lost hope and you think there is no way out, and your financial burdens still persists? Contact us (gaincreditloan1@gmail.com)

Your Name:...............
Your Country:...............
Your Occupation:...............
Loan Amount Needed:...............
Loan Duration...............
Monthly Income:...............
Your Telephone Number:.....................
Business Plan/Use Of Your Loan:...............
Contact Us At : gaincreditloan1@gmail.com

Elite VVIP Models said...

BANGALORE ESCORTS OFFER SOMETHING OUT OF THE BOX!


Bangalore Escorts

Escorts in Bangalore

Independent Bangalore Escorts

Escort Bangalore

Bangalore Escort Agency

abidinmohd said...

Do you need a quick long or short term loan with a relatively low interest rate as low as 3%? We offer business loan, personal loan, home loan, auto loan,student loan, debt consolidation loan e.t.c. no matter your credit score. We are guaranteed in giving out financial services to our numerous clients all over world. With our flexible lending packages, loans can be processed and transferred to the borrower within the shortest time possible, contact our specialist for advice and finance planning. If you need a quick loan contact us via Email: abidinmohdmostafaloanfirm@gmail.com Whats App +918929593217

angelenaalessandro said...

It is a good idea to employ a professional company to install the valves for you. This is because there are many dangers in installing them by yourself. Get detailed info about control valves on this site.

Jessica world smith said...

When you search the net for the best wallet tracker you are going to find that there are several different ones to choose from. Here are some of the best wallet tracker that I have found that I use myself and that my friends also use on a daily basis. This website is great source of wearable sleep tracker.

TRIK JACKPOT POKER said...

This article is very good, I like this article
Slot
Slot Pulsa
Agen Slot Pulsa
slot online
Situs Judi Slot Terpercaya




Escort Girls Service said...

Nice blog and absolutely outstanding. You can do something much better but i still say this perfect.Keep trying for the Escort Girls Service.

Escort Girls Service
Escort Service In Delhi
Mumbai Escorts Service
Call Girl In Chennai
Call Girl In Hyderabad
Call Girl In Bangalore

Our Service Partners :

Refrigerator Repair Service
Online B2B Marketplace
Satta King

Satta King Guru said...

Very nice information, it is valuable and useful to so many people. Thanks for sharing this blog. Get In Touch with Us
SattaKing Gali
Satta King Chart
SattaKing desawar
SattaKingGhaziabad
Satta King2020
Satta King Gali
SattaKing chart
SattaKing Gali
Satta King Chart
SattaKing Gali
Satta King Chart
SattaKing desawar
SattaKingGhaziabad
Satta King2020
Satta King Gali
SattaKing chart
Satta King
SattaKing
GhaziabadSatta King
chart Satta King
SattaKing
Satta King
Gali Satta King
Escort Service
Repair Services
Online Marketing Services
B2B Marketing

feeltheheaven said...


Our Hyderabad Female escort girl you book through us feels the same as your girlfriend because she casually appears in front of you with impressive looks, which attracts you. The girl talks and behaves with you like a friend there you can quickly get into her closeness and explore your way of entering the erotic world. In that kind of a scenario will suggest some things you may implement at that time. Follow us:-

Female Escorts Hyderabad
Hyderabad Escorts
Hyderabad call girls
Call Girls in Hyderabad
Escorts in Hyderabad,
Hyderabad Escorts Agency
Hyderabad Independent Escorts
Independent Hyderabad Escorts

VIP Escorts in Hyderabad

Independent Escorts Hyderabad

Online Front said...

Usually, I never comment on post but your article is convincing. You're doing a great job, keep it up.

Online Front is a digital design and digital marketing agency that offers wide range of digital marketing and website design services.

VISIT AND GET OUR SERVICES:-
Digital Marketing Company in Delhi

Website Design and Development Comapany in Delhi

Social Media Management Company in delhi

Lokesh said...

I think this is a really good article. You make this information interesting and engaging. You give readers a lot to think about and I appreciate that kind of writing.
Read More:
Best Astrologer in Delhi
Ad in Newspaper
Best Courses in India

LiAn Gemstone said...

vòng chuỗi thạch anh tóc đen tự nhiên
Giới thiệu về Thạch anh tóc đen
Thạch anh tóc đen là một biến thể của đá thạch anh có một nguồn năng lượng rất cao, có tên khoa học là Tourmalated Quartz (Tourmalinated Quartz) và những sợi tóc đó chính là tourmaline đen
Thạch anh tóc đen có công dụng gì?
- Thạch anh tóc đen là viên đá hộ thân mạnh mẽ giúp bạn phòng tránh vẩn khí và sự quấy nhiễu của các hư khí xung quanh.
- Giúp bạn hoà đồng với mọi người xoá đi sự sợ hãi. Gặp được nhiều may mắn, vui vẻ và luôn lạc quan.
- Giúp gắn kết tình cảm, hàn gắn các viết thương lòng.
đá mã não
vòng đá tourmaline tự nhiên
thạch anh hồng
đá đào hoa

Unknown said...

Tplinkrepeater.net assists you in accessing the Tp Link WiFi Repeater Configuration Page, which makes it easy for users to set up and expand their networks without any problem.
Your wireless network's Wi-Fi range can be extended and improved with the aid of a Tp-link wifi extender configuration. It provides the most robust, consistent network and smart phone coverage. To finish the tp-link wifi extender configuration, enter the default IP address of 192.168.2.1. Additionally, read the next parts for additional similar tp link range extender troubleshooting advice.

Sheetal said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Johan battler said...

Here is the detail of Watch Fox 505 Live Cricket World World Cup 2023 Streaming Free. Fox 505 Live is a very well-known channel for live broadcasting of sports, entertainment shows.

INR PLUS said...

Great blog! I thoroughly enjoyed reading your post. Home Loan – Get a home loan with INR PLUS at attractive interest rates in India. Explore our variety of housing loan products and apply online.